Independent hospitality journalismSearch & archive
Beyond the headlines.
Into the business.
The Journal
Editor’s Letter

A busy room is not a business model

This week’s results and policy debate show why hospitality needs to distinguish demand from a return worth earning.

There is a particular kind of hospitality announcement that leaves me wanting to see the next page.

Record sales. More sites. Strong demand. All encouraging. Then I want to know what was left after serving those customers, and how much money had to be put in to make it happen.

That is not a fashionable question when the room is full. It is a fairly important one when the rent is due.

This week has offered plenty of reasons to ask it. Britain’s economy grew in the third quarter, but food and beverage service output fell. Accommodation moved the other way. Anyone looking for a single sentence to describe the state of hospitality is going to need a very generous semicolon.

There are successful businesses within that picture. Young’s has reported strong like-for-like growth. Its newly acquired Cubitt House business gives it another route into premium London hospitality. Those are interesting opportunities. They do not remove the need to examine the return on the money invested.

Cubitt’s reported post-acquisition contribution was £11.6 million of revenue and £0.2 million of operating profit. A partial period cannot settle whether an acquisition will pay off. Nor should an appealing growth story settle the question before the evidence does.

The same distinction matters at the other end of the scale. A small independent can be busy and vulnerable at the same time. A handful of additional covers may improve the evening enormously, or require another person on the rota and leave very little extra behind. The answer depends on the operation, not the applause.

Which brings me to yesterday’s VAT debate in Parliament. The case for helping hospitality is serious. So is the question of how relief would work. James Murray put the estimated annual cost of reducing VAT on accommodation and food and beverage services from 20% to 10% at about £11 billion, and said the Treasury’s calculation already allows for behavioural effects. We should argue with the assumptions where the evidence warrants it, rather than treat the whole figure as if nobody had thought about customers spending more.

I would also like the industry to be clear about what it wants a cut to achieve. Lower prices, better wages, repaired balance sheets and investment are all defensible uses. They cannot all absorb the same pound. A business using relief to rebuild its finances is not necessarily failing to pass on a benefit. It may be making sure it can still employ people next year.

A sensible test would ask what changed afterwards: investment completed, jobs sustained, hours offered, businesses surviving and customers returning. The proposed Northern Ireland pilot discussed yesterday could create an opportunity to learn, if it were adopted and properly measured. It is a proposal, not a concession operators can put into next year’s budget.

There is a parallel responsibility inside the business. We cannot ask government for evidence-led policy while making our own investment decisions on a collection of attractive photographs and a turnover forecast.

Before signing another lease, I would want the quiet-day economics explained as carefully as the Saturday-night ambition. Before adding an activity, I would want to know whether it brings a new visit or merely occupies a customer already there. Before calling an acquisition a success, I would want a credible path from sales to cash after the work needed to keep the place good.

None of that is an argument for standing still. Hospitality needs people willing to open things, improve things and occasionally take an unfashionable chance. A spreadsheet cannot tell you whether a room has a soul. It can tell you whether the room requires a miracle every Tuesday.

The best operators will make their own opportunities in this uneven market. They deserve tax and investment decisions that understand how the business works. They also deserve a better definition of success than being busy.

A full room is a lovely sight. I would still turn the page.

Sources

Share this article

LinkedInFacebookXWhatsAppEmail

Keep the conversation going.

Have a view that adds to this story? Write to Michael.

Join the daily brief