Pubs gained transactions. Restaurants lost them. Look beneath the recovery headline.
October’s spending figures point to two different trading conditions. They do not prove that diners have simply decamped to the pub.
Hospitality spending is up. Before we order the champagne, which hospitality are we talking about?
October’s card-spending figures show bars, pubs and clubs taking 4.7% more money than a year earlier, with transactions up 5.7%. Restaurants, cafés and bakeries managed a 0.5% rise in spending, while transactions fell 1.6%.
For the pub category, money taken grew more slowly than transactions. For the restaurant category, spending edged higher despite fewer transactions. The average amount attached to a transaction therefore moved in opposite directions. That is a more revealing starting point than a single number for eating and drinking.
It is tempting to declare that diners are abandoning restaurants for cheaper evenings at the pub. These figures cannot establish that. They do not track the same person changing venues, and transactions are not guest counts. Different occasions, prices, customer mixes and purchasing patterns can all move the totals.
But they do challenge the idea that an operator can read a sector-wide recovery straight into its own budget. A restaurant maintaining revenue through a higher average transaction faces a different problem from a pub handling more transactions for relatively less money each time. One may need to recover lost transaction volume; the other needs to know whether the extra activity is paying its way.
Earlier business intelligence, gathered over six weeks to early October, adds an awkward detail: hospitality, leisure and accommodation businesses reported more promotional activity than normal, with stronger performance at the premium and value ends of the market. That describes competitive pressure, rather than a comfortable opportunity to put prices up.
The distinction I would watch is incremental demand. Filling genuinely empty capacity with a sensible offer can be excellent business. Giving a discount to somebody who would have visited anyway is a rather expensive way of looking busy. The same sales uplift can contain either outcome.
October offers encouragement, particularly for pubs. What it does not tell us is how much margin survives the additional activity. That is the question worth taking into Christmas, before every full table is counted as a victory.
Sources
October card-spending report coverage · Corroborating report · Bank of England business intelligence, 30 October
Share this article
Keep the conversation going.
Have a different view or experience that adds to this story? Write to Michael.
Get the free daily brief