← Back to The Journal
Business & policy

Fewer vacancies, but not necessarily a healthier business

November ONS figures, weakening food-service output and the youth NI proposal raise a harder question: are operators finding staff or struggling to afford them?

Updated 17 November 2026: added the government’s initial response to the Milburn review, distinguishing announced employment-support commitments from recommendations still under consideration.

Updated 17 November 2026: added the final Milburn review’s conditional proposal for a phased increase in the employer National Insurance threshold for workers aged 21–24.

Updated 17 November 2026: added ONS clarification on the industries behind the third-quarter output figures and their limits when interpreting hospitality's hiring slowdown.

There is a comforting way to read this morning's employment figures: hospitality has fewer vacancies, so perhaps its staffing problems are easing. There is a less comfortable interpretation: businesses are becoming more reluctant to recruit. The evidence does not justify choosing one explanation for the whole sector, but it does give us reasons to look beyond the headline.

Accommodation and food service businesses had an estimated 69,000 vacancies in August to October, down 8,000, or 10.1%, over the year. Against May to July, the fall was 2,000, or 2.7%. The vacancy rate declined to 2.7%, from 3.0% a year earlier. The latest estimate is provisional and the comparison figures have been revised. These seasonally adjusted survey estimates count vacancies, not redundancies. ONS vacancies by industry

A vacant position filled successfully and a position abandoned because the business cannot justify the cost can both reduce that total. One is a recruitment success. The other may mean fewer opening hours, a more restricted offer or the same work falling on fewer shoulders. The vacancy figures alone cannot tell us which is happening.

The pressure is not just on the payroll

Look alongside last week's output figures and the picture becomes more interesting. Food and beverage service output fell 1.9% in the three months to September compared with the previous quarter, its fifth consecutive decline on this rolling three-month measure. Yet accommodation output rose 2.5%. The combined accommodation and food services sector contracted 0.5%, while the wider economy grew 0.7%. ONS September GDP release

ONS has since supplied a more detailed explanation of that divergence. Luke Croydon, its Chief Media Officer for Economic Statistics, told MDE Insights that most of the quarterly weakness in food and beverage services came from the 56.2 industry group. That covers event catering and other food service activities, including contract catering. On the accommodation side, growth came from both hotels and the wider group covering holiday and short-stay accommodation, camping, caravan parks and other accommodation.

That makes the distinction within hospitality more important, not less. The food-service total is not a restaurant-only measure, and its decline should not be read as evidence that every pub or restaurant experienced the same trading pattern. Nor can the output breakdown explain why the combined sector's vacancy count fell: the output and vacancy figures cover different periods and do not provide linked evidence about individual employers’ hiring decisions.

These are inflation-adjusted output measures, not profit figures. The ONS methodology uses business turnover and other data to estimate changes in activity, adjusting for prices and seasonal patterns. A business can sell more and still retain less if the cost of delivering those sales rises faster.

This morning's wider labour-market release adds another warning. Across the economy, vacancies fell by 22,000 to 690,000. The largest reduction by employer size was also 22,000, among businesses with one to nine employees. The ONS says smaller firms report that labour costs and other economic conditions are affecting hiring. That is economy-wide evidence, not a hospitality-specific finding, but it is a clear reason not to describe falling vacancies simply as relief. ONS November labour market overview

Nor should slower wage growth be confused with a falling wage bill. Private-sector regular pay was still growing at 3.1% annually. ONS November labour market overview For an operator deciding whether to open a quiet additional service, the relevant question remains whether the extra sales will cover the extra staffing and other avoidable costs, not whether national wage growth has slowed.

What would youth NI relief actually change?

The final Milburn review now recommends a five-year path towards lower employer National Insurance costs for workers aged 21–24, starting with hospitality and retail. Rather than a blanket exemption, it proposes progressively raising the threshold from £5,000 to £10,000 when fiscal conditions allow. The pace would be decided at successive fiscal events and remain subject to the fiscal rules. This is an independent recommendation, not an implemented payroll change or confirmation that the government has adopted it. Milburn review: From a welfare state to a working state, paragraphs 269–273

Responding to advance reports on Monday, UKHospitality estimated that approximately 240,000 sector jobs could benefit, with potential annual savings of £170 million. These are the association’s estimates, not a government costing or evidence of jobs already created. UKHospitality response

The potential benefit is tangible, but its mechanics matter. At the current standard 15% employer rate, an additional £5,000 exempt band implies a maximum £750 annual gross saving per eligible employee once the proposed £10,000 threshold was fully reached, assuming that rate remained unchanged. In a simplified annualised illustration, assuming stable eligibility and pay and excluding Employment Allowance, £20,000 earnings generate £2,250 of employer NI under the existing £5,000 threshold, compared with £1,500 under a £10,000 threshold. That illustrates the eventual threshold, not an immediate saving or the funding for another full-time job. HMRC employer rates

The actual cash saving could be smaller. Eligible employers can already offset up to £10,500 of annual employer NI through Employment Allowance. If that covers the entire liability before and after a change, the immediate NI cash bill remains zero. Under-21s and eligible apprentices under 25 also already have separate employer relief, so “young people” are not a single, newly relieved payroll category. HMRC employer ratesEmployment Allowance

What the government has committed to

The government has now committed to bringing Jobs Guarantee support forward to 12 months of unemployment, rather than 18 months, from spring 2027. It has also committed to an Opportunity and Support Guarantee and a locally led service bringing together employment, skills, health and wider support. A new Youth Opportunities Unit, chaired by Alan Milburn, will coordinate work across government and report directly to the Prime Minister. Government response to the Milburn review, HCWS479, 17 November 2026; Alan Milburn appointed Chair of the new Youth Opportunities Unit, 17 November 2026.

These announcements do not amount to acceptance of every recommendation in Milburn’s report. The initial response does not announce adoption of the proposed employer National Insurance threshold increase or the proposed grant increases. Ministers will consider the wider recommendations alongside the Timms review and set out detailed proposals in a White Paper in early 2027. Operators should therefore continue to distinguish the policy commitments now made from possible future payroll relief.

These distinctions matter to policy. Relief on existing staff can help preserve hours, improve cash flow or protect a marginal service. It does not follow that every supported job is an additional job. The policy question is whether a concession changes an employer's next hiring decision, rather than simply reducing the cost of a decision already made.

For me, that is the central issue. We should welcome serious attempts to make employment more affordable without pretending that a lower vacancy count proves the problem is solved, or that a targeted tax saving restores demand. Hospitality needs both customers willing to spend and an operating model capable of turning that spending into sustainable employment. This morning's figures suggest we should be testing both, not celebrating one number in isolation.

Sources

Share this article

LinkedInFacebookXWhatsAppEmail

Keep the conversation going.

Have a view that adds to this story? Write to Michael.

Join the daily brief